PMG Santos et al. NEJM 2025; 393: 105-107. Who Will Care for America? Immigration Policy and the Coming Health Workforce Crisis

This article outlines the role of undocumented immigrants in our health care system with a focus on home health aides. Given the increase in the numbers of Americans older than 65 yrs, 56 million in 2020 and projected to be 80 million in 2030, current immigration policies will worsen the severe health care worker shortages.

An excerpt:

Immigrants are a vital part of the U.S. health care system: at least one in five U.S. health care workers is foreign-born, including 29% of physicians, 17% of nurses, and 24% of direct care workers…Data suggest that most (if not all) foreign-born physicians and nurses are naturalized U.S. citizens or lawfully permanent residents. In contrast, of the 37% of foreign-born direct care workers who are noncitizens, nearly half may be undocumented.⁴ This divergence is at least partly attributable to policies that streamline pathways to legal permanent residency or citizenship for some but not all immigrants…

As federal policies threaten to further destabilize the direct care workforce, nonimmigrants are unlikely to fill the resulting void. Direct care workers assist with household chores as well as bathing, dressing, and toileting — thereby enabling frail, older adults and those with disabilities to live safely at home….The physically demanding nature of direct care work, combined with low pay and high susceptibility to exploitation, makes these roles unattractive to U.S.-born and highly skilled foreign-born workers…

This is not the first time that immigrants have helped fill critical health care roles that were unattractive to U.S.-born workers…the Exchange Visitor Program in 1948, allowing Filipino nurses to obtain temporary work visas. Later, the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 allowed Filipino nurses to stay in the United States permanently…

Federal officials could effectuate immigration reform in a way that secures our borders while addressing labor shortages. Instead, current policies threaten to further shrink this essential workforce, maligning and driving out hard-working immigrants at the expense of an aging America…compromising care for older adults and the health care system at large…

The recent deportation of immigrant health care workers is our canary in the coal mine: policymakers must act swiftly, or risk endangering the health of us all.

My take: I doubt the consequences of mass deportation have been carefully considered amid the heated rhetoric. There is saying, often attributed to Otto von Bismarck: “Only a fool learns from his own mistakes. A wise man learns from the mistakes of others.” As such, it appears that we are destined to learn from mistakes rather than avoiding them.

Related blog posts:

• How Putting America First is Undermining Health Outcomes Here and Globally
• Providing Care and Upholding the Law in an Evolving Immigration Landscape
• Calamitous Impact of U.S. Withdrawal from Gavi Funding
• America Needs Immigrant (Doctors) 2017
• Immigrant Doctors Blocked by New Rules Too