I Papanicolas, JF Figueroa. N Engl J Med 2026;395:1773-1775. Private Health Insurance and Profit — Lessons for the United States
This article reviews how many other countries constrain private health insurance profits and how these policies could help the U.S.
An excerpt:
The United States is in the midst of a health care affordability crisis. Health insurance premiums and out-of-pocket costs strain households and employers, and public health care spending continues to grow. Yet the largest for-profit health insurers are generating substantial enterprise-level profits. In 2025, UnitedHealth Group reported approximately $12.1 billion in net income, Cigna Group $6 billion, Elevance Health $5.7 billion, and Humana $1.2 billion.1…
In Switzerland, competing private insurers provide compulsory basic insurance. Any surpluses cannot be distributed to shareholders and must remain within the compulsory-insurance business….
Australia and Singapore provide universal coverage primarily through public programs while allowing commercial insurers to sell coverage for additional services or amenities and for care provided by an expanded group of clinicians and hospitals. In Germany, nearly 90% of the population is covered by nonprofit statutory sickness funds; commercial insurers provide comprehensive coverage to slightly more than 10% of the population, including higher-income employees, civil servants, and self-employed people. These models maintain substantial markets for private insurance while limiting shareholder returns associated with financing essential care…
There can be roles for both private insurance and profit in systems that set clear boundaries around commercial returns. The United States has generally drawn these boundaries more permissively and less consistently than other countries. At a time when households, employers, and public payers are struggling to afford health care, we believe policymakers should reconsider whether dollars collected to finance essential care — particularly taxpayer dollars — should be readily available to generate returns for shareholders.
My take: There is definitely a need to improve the U.S. system. The “devil is in the details.”

Related blog posts:
- High Health Care Costs: Plenty of Blame to Go Around
- Why Corporatization Occurs in Health Care -What Motivates Hospitals
- Why Corporatization Occurs in Health Care
- Unpacking Health Care Corporatization in the U.S.
Understanding the Business of Medicine and Downstream Consequences - Medical Billing Trap: Hospital Pricing for Urgent Care Visits and Outpatient Departments
- What Is Driving Hospitals’ Acqui$ition of Physician Practices?
- Healthcare: “Where the Frauds Are Legal”
- Dr. John Barnard: Trends in Pediatric Workforce — A Growing Concern One of the slides shows a 3000% growth in the number of adminstrators/managers in health care from 1970 to 2015.