Atul Gawande: “Tell Me Where It Hurts”

In a recent New Yorker article (Jan 23, 2017, pgs 36-45,LINK:  “Tell Me Where It Hurts” –thanks to Stan Cohen for this article), Atul Gawande provides a compelling narrative on the ‘heroism’ of incremental care.

He starts his narrative with the story of Bill Haynes who had had severe migraines for four decades, but eventually improved under the care of Elizabeth Loder (John Graham Headache Center).  Over the course of four years, her ‘systematic incrementalism had done what nothing else had.’

Dr. Gawande explains that chronic illness is commonplace but “we have been poorly prepared to deal with it.  Much of what ails us requires a more patient kind of skill.  I was drawn to medicine by the aura of heroism–by the chance to charge in and solve a dangerous problem.”

Despite the appeal of dramatic medical moments, bigger impacts are noted with more subtle care. “States with higher ratios of primary care physicians have lower rates of general mortality, infant mortality, and mortality from specific conditions such as heart disease and stroke.”  One of the ways mortality is reduced is getting seen sooner for medical problems. Having a relationship with a physician “has a powerful effect on your willingness to seek care for severe symptoms.”

A parallel narrative in this piece regards the Silver Bridge tragedy in 1967.  This bridge which connected Gallipolis, Ohio and Point Pleasant, West Virginia, over the Ohio River, keeled over and resulted in 46 deaths and dozens more who were injured. This tragedy sparked attention towards infrastructure and trying to address problems before a critical collapse occurs.  “We will all turn out to have –like the Silver Bridge and the growing crack in its critical steel link–a lurking heart condition or a tumor or a depression or some rare disease that needs to be managed. This is a problem for our healthcare system.  It doesn’t put great value on care that takes time to pay off.”

Other points:

  • Incremental medicine is “at odds with our system’s allocation of rewards…the lowest-paid specialties: pediatrics, endocrinology, family medicine, HIV/infectious disease, allergy/immunology, internal medicine, psychiatry, and rheumatology.”
  • “More than a quarter of Americans and Europeans who die before the age of seventy-five would not have died so soon if they’d received appropriate medical care for their conditions.”
  • “Data indicate that twenty-seven per cent of adults under sixty-five…[have] conditions that make them uninsurable without protections” form the Affordable Care Act.

My take: Fixing an aging bridge may not be as exciting as building a new one –unless you are the aging bridge or depend on that bridge.



1 thought on “Atul Gawande: “Tell Me Where It Hurts”

  1. Pingback: Primary Care Physician Looming Shortage | gutsandgrowth

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.