“We Knew the Coronavirus Was Coming, Yet We Failed”

NY Times: We Knew the Coronavirus Was Coming, Yet We Failed

“The vulnerabilities that Covid-19 has revealed were a predictable outgrowth of our market-based health care system.”

Here’s Why:

1. Ventilators. Operated as businesses, hospitals have zero incentive to stockpile.  A vast storeroom in the basement filled with ventilators that might be needed once in a generation or never?…They are unlikely to do so unless government requires them. We’ve long required ocean liners to have lifeboats and life preservers even though their operators hope to never hit an iceberg.

2. Testing has proved the persistent Achilles’ heel in the U.S. response…[Early on] With requirements for Food and Drug Administration approval expensive and cumbersome, developing a test was a business non-starter…In contrast, South Korea, with its national health system, engaged its private test manufacturers with a plan in January, promising them quick approval for a coronavirus test and the widespread use of it in nationally organized and financed testing.

3. Testing components and P.P.E.  …Conducting tests involves access to a number of components — kits, chemical reagents, swabs, personal protective equipment, sometimes custom cartridges for machines. Miss any one of those things and testing becomes impossible. It’s like trying to make bread with all the ingredients except yeast….Without a national system for such purchases in a crisis, we are essentially forcing hospitals and states to negotiate the price of water during a drought. (Alternatively, we could require all hospitals to have a 90-day supply of essential response items on hand, as Gov. Andrew Cuomo of New York has now done.)

4. Hospitals did not coordinate...In our market-based system, hospitals are primed to compete, not coordinate

5. The hospital rescue... [is needed] partly because they have delivered extraordinary treatment of Covid-19 (which doesn’t pay well) but also because they’ve had to cancel high-profit procedures like joint replacements and sophisticated scans to make room for this low-profit-margin illness…In a functioning health system, pandemic preparedness and response would be part of the expected job.

Whether regulated or run by the government, or motivated by new incentives, we need a system that responds more to illness and less to profits.

Related article: NY Times: How Health Insurers Can Be Heroes. Really.

“The industry is profiting from the pandemic. It needs to pay back by cutting premiums and co-payments, help private practices and finance more protection and care…A great paradox of this pandemic is that while Covid-19 is overwhelming the health care system, health care spending is down a whopping 18 percent. ”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.