Breastfeeding Associated with Infant Survival

JL Ware et al. Am J Prev Med 2023; 65: 763-774. Associations Between Breastfeeding and Post-perinatal Infant Deaths in the U.S

This study examined a prospective cohort linking data on breastfeeding on birth certificates (starting in 2016) to infant death rates. This included 9,711,567 live births and 20,632 post-perinatal infant deaths.

Key findings:

  • The overall adjusted OR for breastfeeding initiation with post-perinatal infant mortality was 0.67.
  • Table 1 provides a ton of information about demographics and associated outcomes: Better education was associated with lower post-perinatal (7-365 days) death rate per 1,000 births. College graduate rate was 0.91 compared to 3.43 for lower than high school. Age 30-34 was 1.53 compared to 3.87 for <20 years. Non-hispanic Asian, Non-Hispanic White, and Hispanic were 1.11, 1.79 and 1.58 and much better than Non-Hispanic Black which was 4.07. Smoking during pregnancy rate was 5.68 compared to 1.83 for non-smoking during pregnancy
  • Preterm infant had a much higher post-perinatal mortality rate: 7.97 vs 1.36 for term babies

One limitation that may contribute to an underestimate of the advantages of breastfeeding -this study determines only initiation of breastfeeding. Breastfeeding duration of >3 months has been associated with decreased infant mortality. In other words, in infants with longer breastfeeding, the advantages are likely to be more pronounced. Breastfeeding has been associated with lower rates of necrotizing enterocolitis and sudden unexpected infant deaths.

My take: Breastfeeding appears to confer health benefits to infants and mothers. Some of the improvements in infant mortality likely are due to the association of breastfeeding with other characteristics that reduce infant mortality including education, non- smoking during pregnancy, older mothers and race. The authors note that race is a “social construct, but the systemic or structural disadvantages associated with race contribute to health disparities…A Black infant is 2.4 times more likely to die before his or her first birthday in the U.S. than a White infant.”

Related blog posts:

Mural from Funk Zone in Santa Barbara
Santa Barbara Botanical Gardens

Why It is Still Not a Good Idea to Test Healthy Children for Enteric Pathogens & Infant Mortality Rates Rising in Georgia (& much of U.S.)

BR Lee et al. J Pediatr 2023; 261: 113551. A Comparison of Pathogen Detection and Risk Factors among Symptomatic Children with Gastroenteritis Compared with Asymptomatic Children in the Post-rotavirus Vaccine Era

Patients (<11 yrs old) with acute gastroenteritis (AGE, n=2503) and healthy controls (HC, n=537) old enrolled in the New Vaccine Surveillance Network study between December 2011 to June 2016. Key findings:

  • One or more organisms was detected in 1159 of 2503 children (46.3%) with AGE compared with 99 of 537 HC (17.3%).
  • Norovirus was detected most frequently among AGE (n = 568 [22.7%]). The other frequent pathogens detected were rotavirus 7.8% (despite ~75% vaccinated population), adenovirus 4.8%, C difficile 5.3%, Salmonella 6.4%, and Shigella 4.5%. 63.5% of all pathogens detected were viruses.
  • C difficile was detected more frequently in the HC population (7% vs 5.3%). E coli infections, likewise, were very commonly observed in the HC population (2.1% vs 1.1%). The false positive rates for C difficile pathogenicity would have been higher if the authors had not restricted their analysis to >12 months for C diff. The rates of Norovirus and Rotavirus in the HC group was 6.8% and 2.6% respectively.
  • Codetection of multiple pathogens was common. For example, with norovirus, 20.8% had a copathogen detected. Salmonella and C difficile had the highest codection rates of 53.5% and 54.5% respectively.

This study shows substantial improvement in rotavirus infections with a drop from 26% in detection prior to vaccine era to 6% afterwards.

My take: These muliplex molecular assays are quite useful and have improved our ability to determine underlying infections. This is particularly useful in children with underlying diseases (eg. IBD, malignancy). However, this report serves as a cautionary note that many pathogens, including C diff and E coli, are frequently identified with PCR assays in healthy children

Related blog posts:

In 2022, 892 infants died in Georgia, an increase of 116 from prior year. About 7 infants dying for every 1000 births. AJC 11/1/23: CDC: Georgia’s infant mortality increase is among the worst in U.S.

Bromelia