A survey (O Waisbourd-Zinman, et al. JPGN 2018; 66: 447-49) of 44 pediatric hepatologists (with 935 years of clinical practice) examined the issue of splenic rupture and spleen guards. ~90% of those surveyed reported following at least 30 patients with portal hypertension and splenomegaly.
- In total, the hepatologists could recall 13 cases of splenic rupture among patients with portal hypertension/splenomegaly due to cirrhosis –almost all of these occurred after a fall or in a motor vehicle accident. Only one of these falls happened during a sports-related event (soccer).
- 11 cases were serious. 9 of these cases resulted in shock with subsequent splenectomy, embolization, and/or death. Death reported in 2 cases.
- In this survey, 61% of hepatologists recommended “absolute restriction from activity with high risk of blunt abdominal trauma;” whereas 23% indicated that activities with risk of blunt trauma were acceptable if wearing a spleen guard.
- To prevent splenic rupture in patients with portal hypertension/splenomegaly, among the participating hepatologists, the majority identified the following ‘high risk’ sports: football (95%), hockey (82%), and wrestling (66%). A smaller percentage advocated a spleen guard for skiing (42%), soccer (41%), basketball (30%) and other sports.
While I did not participate in this survey, the one patient with chronic liver disease that I followed who had a splenic rupture had fallen down a flight of steps; fortunately, he recovered with supportive care.
My take: This survey shows that there is wide variability in the use of spleen guards. In almost all cases of splenic rupture, this was precipitated by severe trauma. Though, patients with portal hypertension may avoid high contact sports and thus the risks are for these sports is unclear.
Related blog post: