Tag Archives: liver transplantation cost

Liver Transplantation is Getting More Costly in U.S

Posted on by

A Kaplan et al. Liver Transplantation 2025; 31: 1165-1175. Open Access! The rising cost of liver transplantation in the United States

Key points:

  • LT is resource-intensive and costly, with expenditures rising dramatically in recent years. Factors contributing to this increase in cost include expanded transplant criteria (higher risk recipients), utilization of marginal organs, and broader organ distribution, resulting in significant logistical expenses
  • Advanced technologies like organ perfusion devices, while promising better outcomes, further inflate costs due to their high price and market monopolization
  • Despite rising costs, reimbursement has remained largely stagnant, putting financial strain on transplant programs, and threatening their sustainability. “In fact, there has been an observed decline (−32%) in adjusted reimbursement of LT by Medicare over the past decade.62“

Increased Costs Associated with Recipient Characteristics:

  • “According to the latest annual SRTR report, patients aged 65 or older undergoing LT accounted for 21.9% of transplants in 2022, up from 14.6% a decade prior.18 One study looking at the cost burden of hospitalizations associated with liver transplants from 2016 to 2019 found mean costs increasing by nearly $10,000 per hospitalization in the group aged >65 over the study period”
  • “Increasing numbers of patients are being transplanted for steatotic liver disease… LT associated with metabolic dysfunction–associated steatotic liver disease has been demonstrated to be associated with higher costs, largely attributable to longer posttransplant lengths of stay.21–23 Similarly, LT associated with AH/ALD is very expensive—at 1 transplant program, net revenue from LT admission to 90 days after LT was −5.0% for AH compared to +1.4% for acute-on-chronic liver failure.24“

Organ distribution:

  • “In 2019, the OPTN implemented further changes in liver allocation from a regional-based system to an acuity circle model. This model was intended to create a more equitable allocation system and to reduce waitlist mortality for patients across the United States…This has been associated with a 77% increase in fly-out costs, amounting to an increase in $47,010,190 across all LT centers by recent estimates.4“
  • “1 study found that the cost for private jets ranged from $6850 to $27,350 depending on the distance traveled.29 In this same study, commercial flights, as opposed to private jets, were found to be safe and only around 10% of the cost.”

Perfusion devices:

“The FDA’s approval of organ perfusion and preservation devices has ushered in a new era in organ transplantation, enabling medical teams to extend the geographical reach for organ procurement. These devices enhance the utilization of organs that may have previously been discarded… It has been suggested that the average cost of using normothermic regional perfusion for DCD organs is around $10,000 per donor, compared to the $40,000–$80,000 per donor for use of NMP [normothermic machine perfusion].”

My take: Transplant centers are getting squeezed financially. In addition, ~25% of liver transplant patients experience a high financial burden. Pretty soon, along with checking organs for suitability, it may be necessary to assess liver transplant centers for viability.

Related blog posts:

Osaka Garden in Jackson Park (Chicago)

Costs and Opportunity Costs in Pediatric Liver Transplantation

Posted on by

GV Mazariegos et al. Liver Transplantation 2023; 29: 671-682. Open access! Center use of technical variant grafts varies widely and impacts pediatric liver transplant waitlist and recipient outcomes in the United States

Background: Waitlist (WL) mortality is highest in children under the age of 1 year (12.5 deaths/100 WL years).2 It is thought that TVG (technical variant grafts) [including living donor (LD) and deceased donor split/partial grafts] improve outcomes.

Methods: The authors, in this retrospective study, analyzed Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN) data on first-time LT or liver-kidney pediatric candidates listed at centers that performed >10 LTs during the study period, 2004–2020. 

Key findings:

  • Sixty-four centers performed 7842 LTs; 657 children died on the WL
  • Death from listing was significantly lower with increased center TVG usage (HR = 0.611) and LT volume (HR = 0.995)
  • Recipients of LD transplants (HR = 0.637) had significantly increased survival from transplant compared with other graft types, and recipients of deceased donor TVGs (HR = 1.066) had statistically similar outcomes compared with whole graft recipients

My take (borrowed from authors): “LD partial grafts and overall volume performed by the center in the preceding 3 years was significantly associated with increased post-LT survival. Deceased donor graft type (DD TVG vs. DD Whole) was not a predictor of post-LT survival after accounting for patient diagnosis, center volume, and other significant factors that were predictive of survival. DD TVG should not be considered an inferior graft option in experienced centers…LD grafts are associated with a survival advantage.”

BA Sayed, M Cattral, VL Ng. Liver Transplantation 2023; 29: 663-664. Open access! (editorial) Insufficient use of technical variant grafts: An unfulfilled promise in pediatric liver transplantation Key points:

  • “While outcomes have improved, with current 1- and 5-year patient survival >97% and 94%, respectively, many children continue to die on the waitlist (WL) or are removed because they are too sick.1,2“
  • “As expected, these children were younger, smaller, sicker (more status 1 listings), and remained on the WL longer than children who received a transplant during the same time period…These small infants are particularly at risk because of the difficulty of obtaining an appropriately sized-matched graft. Data indicate that this problem can be solved largely by increasing the use of technical variant grafts (TVGs), which includes living donor (LD) grafts and split/reduced grafts from deceased donors (DDs).4,5“
  • “This manuscript obliquely touches on another pressing issue within the pediatric LT community, namely, the core skill set of a pediatric LT surgeon. Currently, there is no such distinct designation in the North American training environment, and therefore, no training requirements exist. To provide the full spectrum of surgical care, the technical skill set should include LD hepatectomies and graft implantations, DD graft reduction/splitting, the reduction or hyper-reduction of left lateral segment grafts, and staged abdominal closure.”

My take: Where a patient is listed is a very important variable in outcomes. Choosing a low volume center without availability to perform TVG increases the risk of lethal outcomes. This information should be disclosed to families at all centers.

Also: T Miloh et al. Liver Transplantation 2023; 29: 735-744. Open access! Costs of pediatric liver transplantation among commercially insured and Medicaid-insured patients with cholestasis in the US

Health care resource utilization and costs associated with pediatric LT were retrospectively assessed using insurance claims data from the US IBM MarketScan Commercial and Medicaid databases collected between October 2015 and December 2019. Study cohort: 53 commercially insured and 100 Medicaid-insured children

  • Key findings: Commercially insured and Medicaid-insured patients averaged US $512,124 and $211,863 in medical costs and $26,998 and $15,704 in pharmacy costs, respectively

Related blog posts:

Place Massena, Nice France
Le Plongeoir (restaurant) Nice, France

Liver Shorts: Relationship of Hepatic Steatosis to Cardiovascular Disease and the Cost of Liver Transplantation

Posted on by

HS Ahmed et al. Hepatology 2023; 77: 2063-2072. The association between hepatic steatosis and incident cardiovascular disease, cancer, and all-cause mortality in a US multicohort study

The authors included 10,040 participants from the Framingham Heart Study, the Coronary Artery Risk Development in Young Adults Study, and the Multi-ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis to assess the longitudinal association between liver fat (defined on CT) and incident cardiovascular disease (CVD).

Key finding:

Hepatic steatosis was associated with all-cause mortality after 12.7 years of mean follow-up when adjusting for baseline CVD risk factors, including body mass index (HR: 1.21, 1.04–1.40); however, the association between hepatic steatosis and incident CVD was not statistically significant after we accounted for body mass index in models considering baseline covariates or time-varying covariates. We observed no association between hepatic steatosis and CVD-related mortality or incident cancer.

My take: While CVD is the leading cause of mortality in patients with fatty liver disease, this study suggests that hepatic steatosis is a marker for this increased risk rather than an independent cause.

DU Lee et al. Liver Transplantation 2023; 29: 626-643. The trends in cost associated with liver transplantation in the US: Analysis of weighted hospital data

This lengthy article is loaded with data on trends and costs of liver transplantation in the U.S.

Key findings:

  • From 2016 to 2019, the estimated total number of LT-related hospitalizations in the US were 6685, 7075, 7260, and 7815 cases respectively.
  • There was a general increase in the total cost of LT-related hospitalizations over the years: $945.75, $1010.23, $1052.46, and $1143.84 in millions of dollars.

Editorial: A Kaplan et al. Liver Transplantation 2023; 29: 568-569. Open Access!
Liver transplant at all costs Key points:

  • Mean costs per patient for transplant-related hospitalization were around $145,000.
  • “Lee and colleagues’ important study adds to the growing concern over rising costs for LT. However, LT is 1 of many fields that must utilize a scarce resource for the maximal benefit of society. Balancing costs with a life-saving procedure that is very expensive will continue to be a persistent challenge.”

My take: It is likely that the costs of liver transplantation are going to continue to rise unless we develop a shortage of suitable liver donors or a shortage of transplant personnel. Severe fatty liver disease and alcoholic liver disease continue to increase in frequency while hospital costs continue to soar. Reducing costs will rely on reversing the tide of these diseases.

Related blog posts:

Watersound, FL