NYT: Educate Your Immune System

A recent commentary updates the concept of the hygiene theory and how our lack of exposures to a ‘dirtier’ environment when we are younger can make us more prone to autoimmune diseases, including celiac disease, diabetes, and multiple sclerosis.

Here’s the link: Educate Your Immune

Here’s an excerpt:

People living just over the border in Russian Karelia, as the region is known, have the same prevalence of genes linked to autoimmune disease [as in Finland]. They also live at the same latitude and in the same climate. And yet they have a much lower vulnerability to autoimmune disease. Celiac disease and Type 1 diabetes occur about one-fifth and one-sixth as often, respectively, in Russian Karelia as in Finland. Hay fever and asthma, allergic diseases that also signal a tendency toward immune overreaction, are far less common.

So in a follow-up study, the results of which appeared last month in the journal Cell, Dr. Xavier and his colleagues followed 222 children who were genetically at risk of developing autoimmune diabetes. The newborns were equally divided among Finland, Russia and Estonia, where the prevalence of Type 1 diabetes is on the rise, but still well below Finland’s.

Autoimmune diabetes can be predicted, to some degree, by the appearance of certain antibodies in the bloodstream that attack one’s own tissues. After three years, 16 Finnish children and 14 Estonian children had these antibodies; only four Russian children did. And when the scientists compared the children’s microbiomes in the three countries, they found stark differences. A group of microbes called bacteroides dominated in Finnish and Estonian infants. But in Russia, bifidobacteria and E. coli held sway….

Russian kids have more fecal oral infections, such as hepatitis A, suggesting more sharing not only of pathogens, but of microbes that may benefit health. And previous studies have found that Russian homes harbor a richer and more diverse community of microbes than Finnish ones….

The world today is very different from the one our immune system evolved to anticipate — not just in what we encounter, but in when we first encounter it. Preventing autoimmune disorders may require emulating aspects of that “dirtier” world.

Screen Shot 2016-06-03 at 6.23.18 PM

Quantifying Risk of PML with Natalizumab

Given the limited number of treatment options for inflammatory bowel disease, when Natalizumab became available, there was a great deal of enthusiasm.  This quickly diminished as reports of progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy (PML) emerged.  So far, I have not prescribed this agent.

Due to its efficacy for multiple sclerosis and IBD, there has been continued interest in understanding the risk for PML (NEJM 2012; 366: 1870-80, editorial pg 1938-39).

Key findings:

  • 212 cases of PML among 99,571 patients treated with natalizumab (2.1 cases per 1000)
  • Three main risk factors: positive JC-virus antibody, previous use of immunosuppressants, and receiving natalizumab more than 2 years

Patients who were negative for anti-JC virus antibodies had an incidence of 0.09 cases or less per 1000 patients.  Among patients who test positive for anti-JC virus antibodies, the risk remained <1 per 1000 patients if no use of immunosuppressants and 2 per 1000 if prior use of immunosuppressants during the first two years of therapy.  The risks were five-fold higher after 2 years in both groups.

While the risks are becoming more clear, the benefits of natalizumab are fairly well-established for multiple sclerosis.  Natalizumab decreased the annualized rate of relapse among patients with relapsing–remitting multiple sclerosis by 68%.

Additional references:

  • -NEJM 2009; 361: 1067, 1075, 1081.  Asymptomatic detection of JC virus common in urine noted in patients Rx’d with natalizumab (19% baseline to 63% on Rx); actual leukoencephalopathy ~1/1000 patients.
  • -Gastroenterol 2007; 132: 1672.  ENCORE trial.
  • -JPGN 2007; 44: 185. n=31 children/adolescents.  55% response, 29% remission; dosed at 3mg/kg.
  • -IBD 2007; 13: 2.  n=79.  Trial of combination natalizumab & infliximab.
  • -NEJM 2006; 354: 899, 911, 924.  Natalizumab slows progression of MS.  Risk of PML due to JC virus 1:1000 in 18 months of Rx.
  • -NEJM 2005; 353: 1912/1965.  Natalizumab not significantly effective for Crohn’s in this study
  • -NEJM 2005; 353: 362, 369, 375, 414.  3 cases of PML associated with Natalizumab
  • -JPGN 2004; 39: S49 [abstract 0107].  Natalizumab in 38 adolescents was effective (Hyams et al).
  • -Gastroenterol 2004; 126: 1574-81. review.  Natalizumab benefitted subjects with elevated CRP. (dosing 300mg every 4 weeks.)
  • -NEJM 2003; 24-32 & 68.  Natalizumab improved response rates in pts c Crohn’s dz (similar to infliximab).  Drug blocks alpha4 integrins which are required for lymphocytes to enter the intestine.
  • -Gastroenterol 2001; 121: 268-74. Infusion of 3mg/kg decreases CDAI in Crohn’s dz.