Do Gun Law Restrictions Work?

Those opposed to gun safety provisions (a.k.a. gun control legislation) argue that laws  will not prevent criminals from obtaining firearms illegally.  A recent commentary in NY Times provides some data that shows that states with more gun safety provisions have lower levels of gun-related deaths (especially suicides).

NY Times: A Gun Killed My Son. So Why Do I Want to Own One?

Related blog posts:

No Exaggeration: Too Many Children Are Dying in the U.S.

A recent report (RM Cunningham et al. NEJM 2018; 379: 2468-75; editorial 2466-7) highlights the poor outcomes for children in the U.S. based mainly on the CDC WONDER (Wide-ranging Online Data for Epidemiologic Research) database.

Key findings:

  • “The sad fact is that a child or adolescent in the United States is 57% more likely to die by the age of 19 years than those in other wealthy nations.”
  • Motor vehicle accidents (MVA) are the number one cause of deaths in children/adolescents, accounting for 20% of such deaths.  The U.S. rate of death from MVAs is “triple that in other developed countries.”  Overall, MVA deaths had dropped in half from 1999-2013 but have increased in last few years; this increase is thought to be related to distracted driving/walking due to cellphones.
  • Firearm-related deaths accounted for 15% of deaths in children/adolescents in U.S.  In U.S., children/adolescents are “36 times as likely to be killed by gunshots.”  Unlike adults in U.S., the majority of these gunshots are homicides (59%) rather than suicides (35%); unintentional firearm deaths accounted for 4% (2% undetermined firearm-related death).  Among U.S. adults, 62% of deaths from firearms were from suicide.
  • Malignant neoplasms were the third leading mortality cause in children/adolescents, 9%. This rate is similar to other countries.

The figures in the study are very helpful:

  • Figure 2: Deaths from MVAs for the U.S. pediatric population are more similar to low-to-middle income countries (Figure 2A) whereas firearm-related deaths are much greater than all of the countries shown in Figure 2B (including Sweden, England, Hungary, Australia, Austria, Thailand, Tajikistan, Romania, Mongolia).
  • Figure 3. Deaths in U.S. rural areas are roughly double from MVAs than from the average of urban/suburban areas.  Deaths from firearms are similar in all three areas.  There are several factors which could explain the high rate of fatal MVAs in rural areas: longer time to get medical attention, faster speeds in less populous areas, less seat belts, lower enforcement of traffic laws, and impaired driving.

My take: The increased risk of death from MVAs and firearms identified in this study should not be considered “accidents” but failures.  Is it too much to expect that a child born in the U.S. could have the same chance to reach adulthood as a child in Canada or a child in Europe?

Related blog posts:


Another Day in the US: School Deaths Related to Firearms

Between 2001-2013, gun related deaths exceeded the total number of deaths from AIDS, terrorism, war, and illegal drug overdoses combined (according to Vox -see Firearm Mortality in U.S).  Here are some tweets in reaction to yesterday’s tragic events.

Link to The Onion commentary: ‘No Way To Prevent This’

Related blog posts:


A Call to Arms for Health Care Professionals

A recent editorial published simultaneously in NEJM (DB Taichman et al. 2017; 377: 2090-91), Annals of Internal Medicine, PLOS Medicine and JAMA urges physicians:

  • “Don’t be silent. We don’t need more moments of silence to honor the memory of those who have been killed. We need to honor their memory by preventing a need for such moments.”

A short list of how health care professionals can help:

  • “Educate yourself”
  • Contact your local, state, and federal legislators.  “And do it again at regular intervals.”
  • Attend public meetings. “Demand answers, commitments, and follow-up”
  • “Go to rallies.”
  • “Join, volunteer for, or donate to organizations fighting for sensible firearm legislations.”
  • Vote for candidates “with stances that mitigate firearm-related injury.”

My take: I’m proud of my friends who have been trying to make a difference.  If any other medical problem exacted the toll of firearms, it is hard to imagine such complacency/resignation.

Related blog posts:

Sunrise over South Rim of Grand Canyon