Costs and Opportunity Costs in Pediatric Liver Transplantation

GV Mazariegos et al. Liver Transplantation 2023; 29: 671-682. Open access! Center use of technical variant grafts varies widely and impacts pediatric liver transplant waitlist and recipient outcomes in the United States

Background: Waitlist (WL) mortality is highest in children under the age of 1 year (12.5 deaths/100 WL years).2 It is thought that TVG (technical variant grafts) [including living donor (LD) and deceased donor split/partial grafts] improve outcomes.

Methods: The authors, in this retrospective study, analyzed Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN) data on first-time LT or liver-kidney pediatric candidates listed at centers that performed >10 LTs during the study period, 2004–2020. 

Key findings:

  • Sixty-four centers performed 7842 LTs; 657 children died on the WL
  • Death from listing was significantly lower with increased center TVG usage (HR = 0.611) and LT volume (HR = 0.995)
  • Recipients of LD transplants (HR = 0.637) had significantly increased survival from transplant compared with other graft types, and recipients of deceased donor TVGs (HR = 1.066) had statistically similar outcomes compared with whole graft recipients

My take (borrowed from authors): “LD partial grafts and overall volume performed by the center in the preceding 3 years was significantly associated with increased post-LT survival. Deceased donor graft type (DD TVG vs. DD Whole) was not a predictor of post-LT survival after accounting for patient diagnosis, center volume, and other significant factors that were predictive of survival. DD TVG should not be considered an inferior graft option in experienced centers…LD grafts are associated with a survival advantage.”

BA Sayed, M Cattral, VL Ng. Liver Transplantation 2023; 29: 663-664. Open access! (editorial) Insufficient use of technical variant grafts: An unfulfilled promise in pediatric liver transplantation Key points:

  • “While outcomes have improved, with current 1- and 5-year patient survival >97% and 94%, respectively, many children continue to die on the waitlist (WL) or are removed because they are too sick.1,2“
  • “As expected, these children were younger, smaller, sicker (more status 1 listings), and remained on the WL longer than children who received a transplant during the same time period…These small infants are particularly at risk because of the difficulty of obtaining an appropriately sized-matched graft. Data indicate that this problem can be solved largely by increasing the use of technical variant grafts (TVGs), which includes living donor (LD) grafts and split/reduced grafts from deceased donors (DDs).4,5“
  • “This manuscript obliquely touches on another pressing issue within the pediatric LT community, namely, the core skill set of a pediatric LT surgeon. Currently, there is no such distinct designation in the North American training environment, and therefore, no training requirements exist. To provide the full spectrum of surgical care, the technical skill set should include LD hepatectomies and graft implantations, DD graft reduction/splitting, the reduction or hyper-reduction of left lateral segment grafts, and staged abdominal closure.”

My take: Where a patient is listed is a very important variable in outcomes. Choosing a low volume center without availability to perform TVG increases the risk of lethal outcomes. This information should be disclosed to families at all centers.

Also: T Miloh et al. Liver Transplantation 2023; 29: 735-744. Open access! Costs of pediatric liver transplantation among commercially insured and Medicaid-insured patients with cholestasis in the US

Health care resource utilization and costs associated with pediatric LT were retrospectively assessed using insurance claims data from the US IBM MarketScan Commercial and Medicaid databases collected between October 2015 and December 2019. Study cohort: 53 commercially insured and 100 Medicaid-insured children

  • Key findings: Commercially insured and Medicaid-insured patients averaged US $512,124 and $211,863 in medical costs and $26,998 and $15,704 in pharmacy costs, respectively

Related blog posts:

Place Massena, Nice France
Le Plongeoir (restaurant) Nice, France

You No Longer Have Fatty Liver Disease-You Have Steatotic Liver Disease!

A total of 236 panelists from 56 countries participated in four online surveys and two hybrid meetings.

Key points:

  • Steatotic liver disease (SLD) was chosen as an overarching term to encompass the various “aetiologies” of steatosis.
  • The name chosen to replace NAFLD was metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease (MASLD). There was consensus to change the definition to include the presence of at least one of five cardiometabolic risk factors (see 2nd figure).
  • The term steatohepatitis was felt to be an important pathophysiological concept that should be retained. Metabolic dysfunction-associated steatohepatitis (MASH) is the replacement term for NASH.
  • Those with no metabolic parameters and no known cause were deemed to have cryptogenic SLD.
  • A new category, outside pure MASLD, termed MetALD was selected to describe those with MASLD who consume greater amounts of alcohol per week (140 to 350 g/week and 210 to 420 g/week for females and males respectively). 

AASLD News Digest: “MASLD, formerly known as NAFLD, is the most common chronic liver disease around the world, affecting more than 30% of global population. This was why it was vital that the global liver community coalesce around an affirmative, non-stigmatizing name and diagnosis. Ultimately, the global members of the Nomenclature Development Initiative were focused on ensuring the global community had better nomenclature that could be used around the world so that the research and funding could be better directed to save more people’s lives.”

My take: NAFLD is now MASLD –time to update patient handouts (hopefully someone at GIKids.org is on top of this). Aslo, if you have really bad disease, should it be called the ‘monster MASH’ ?

Sad Commentary on Gun Violence & Drop in Biliary Atresia Cases During Pandemic

Today.com 5/5/23: Should 3rd graders learn how to use tourniquets for school shootings? Texas bill says yes

——

A Arshad et al. JPGN 2023; 76: 424-427. Reduced Presentation of Biliary Atresia During the COVID-19 Lockdown: A Population Based Observational Study

Methods: This population study assessed all confirmed cases of BA, from January 2020 to December 2021 across the 3 UK pediatric liver centers originating from England and Wales. Data was then compared to the incidence of confirmed BA cases from January to December 2017, 2018, and 2019.

Key findings -BA cases:

  • 2017: 16
  • 2018: 13
  • 2019: 18
  • 2020: 8
  • 2021: 12
  • This difference was significant in a two-sided t test for 2020 (P = 0.035) but not for 2021 (P = 0.385)

The authors note that new BA diagnoses were reduce among Danish centers as well. In their discussion, the authors discuss the possibility of missed diagnosis versus an actual drop in BA cases. The later is intriguing due to concerns that perinatal infections could trigger BA.

My take: This study provides a piece of a puzzle regarding the etiology of BA, indicating a good likelihood of environmental/infectious etiologies as a trigger.

Related blog posts:

Can Ceftriaxone Be Given (Safely) to Infants with Unconjugated Hyperbilirubinemia?

SB Amin. J Pediatr 2023; 254: 91-95. Bilirubin-Displacing Effect of Ceftriaxone in Infants With Unconjugated Hyperbilirubinemia Born at Term

This prospective study with 27 term infants (<7 days) with mild unconjugated hyperbilirubinemia (total bilirubin 6-12 mg/dL) (to convert to micromol/L multiple by 17.1) and with sepsis. Free bilirubin concentrations were measured by the peroxidase method using a UB analyzer and a Zone Fluidics device before (baseline) and 15 minutes after (follow-up) IV ceftriaxone administration on postnatal days 4 to 6.

Key findings:

  • The mean free bilirubin (μg/dL) at follow-up was not different from that at baseline when measured by the UB analyzer (P = .78). The mean free bilirubin was significantly lower at follow-up compared with baseline when measured by the Zone Fluidics device (P = .02). The ratio of a free bilirubin with and without ceftriaxone, an index of displacing effect, was 1.02 (95% CI 0.89-1.14) using the UB analyzer and 0.58 (95% CI 0.30-0.86) using the Zone Fluidics device.

Ceftriaxone has been considered contraindicated in the presence of neonatal unconjugated hyperbilirubinemia due to concern of bilirubin displacement from albumin, resulting in elevated serum free bilirubin (& risk of kernicterus). However, “most of the evidence for the bilirubin-displacing effect of IV ceftriaxone has been derived from in vitro studies.”

My take: This study indicates that there is no significant effect of ceftriaxone in increasing free bilirubin in term infants with mild unconjugated hyperbilirubin

Related blog posts:

Tucson Botanical Gardens

Disclaimer: This blog, gutsandgrowth, assumes no responsibility for any use or operation of any method, product, instruction, concept or idea contained in the material herein or for any injury or damage to persons or property (whether products liability, negligence or otherwise) resulting from such use or operation. These blog posts are for educational purposes only. Specific dosing of medications (along with potential adverse effects) should be confirmed by prescribing physician.  Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, the gutsandgrowth blog cautions that independent verification should be made of diagnosis and drug dosages. The reader is solely responsible for the conduct of any suggested test or procedure.  This content is not a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment provided by a qualified healthcare provider. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a condition.

Current Practice in Hepatitis B and Long-term Prospects

Sendero Esperanza Trail, Saguaro National Park, Tucson AZ

D Yardeni et al. Gastroenterol 2023; 164: 42-60. Open Access! Current Best Practice in Hepatitis B Management and Understanding Long-term Prospects for Cure

This is a very helpful review. Table 1 lists treatment indications by group. For example, AASLD recommendations:

  • Table 3 compares the effectiveness of current treatments
  • Table 4 describes the large number (~50) of antiviral agents in development and their mechanism of action
  • The authors recommend HCC surveillance in those with cirrhosis every 6 months with ultrasound with or without serum AFP
  • “Although current therapy is associated with improved clinical outcome, it is not curative because of a lack of effect on cccDNA and integrated HBV DNA. Stopping therapy in the absence of HBsAg loss usually leads to relapse to active disease in most patients and thus treatment must be administered long term.”
  • “Many challenges remain, the sheer breadth of therapeutic approaches in development holds great promise for curing and eliminating chronic HBV infection”

My take: While it is likely that newer medications will help many with chronic hepatitis B, the best hope for eliminating HBV continues to be with prevention and vaccination.

Related article: J-F Wu et al. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol 2023; 21: 663-669. Baseline Hepatitis B Virus Surface Antigen Titers in Childhood Predict the Risk of Advanced Liver Fibrosis in Adulthood

Key finding: In this study with more than 30 years of prospective followup (n=214): n a multivariate analysis, both an HBsAg titer >4.44 log10 IU/mL at 15 years of age and HBV genotype C were predictors of advanced fibrosis (odds ratios, 15.43 and 4.77; P = .01 and P = .02, respectively).

Related blog posts:

Lecture: IBAT Inhibitor for Alagille Syndrome

I recently attended an online lecture which reviewed Alagille Syndrome and the emergence of an IBAT inhibitor for the management of cholestatic pruritus. Selected slides from Mirum Pharmaceutical Lecture: “Updates in the Treatment of Cholestatic Pruritus in Patients With Alagille Syndrome.” *I have no financial disclosures or conflict of interests in this medication or company.

  • The severe itching which is seen in most patients with Alagille is often quite detrimental to quality of life. It impacts sleep, causes irritability, skin damage, and physical distcomfort
  • Typically, the first week of receiving the medication, it is started at1/2 the maintenance dose.
  • Monitoring response can be done with the ItchCheck App, Itch score or Clinical scratch score
  • Monitoring hepatic blood tests and periodic monitoring of fat soluble vitamins is recommended

My take: Though Alagille syndrome is a multisystem disease, improvement in pruritus due to cholestasis with an oral daily medication is an important advance/option. There is little systemic absorption and thus far a reassuring safety profile.

Related blog posts:

AASLD 2023 Practice Guidance for Primary Sclerosing Cholangitis and Cholangiocarcinoma

CL Bowlus et al. Hepatology 2023; 77: 659-702. Open Access! AASLD practice guidance on primary sclerosing cholangitis and cholangiocarcinoma

This is a lengthy article with a great deal of useful information. Here are some of the important recommendations most relevant for pediatric gastroenterologists/hepatologists:

  • In patients with PSC without known inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), diagnostic colonoscopy with histological sampling should be performed and may be repeated every 5 years if IBD is not initially detected
  • In patients with PSC in whom IBD is diagnosed, high‐definition surveillance colonoscopy with biopsies should start at age 15 years and be repeated at 1‐year to 2‐year intervals to evaluate for colonic dysplasia
  • New clinical risk tools for PSC are available for risk stratification, but probabilities of events in individual patients should be interpreted with caution
  • All patients with PSC should be considered for participation in clinical trials; however, ursodeoxycholic acid (13–23 mg/kg/day) can be considered and continued if well tolerated with a meaningful improvement in alkaline phosphatase (γ‐glutamyl transferase in children) and/or symptoms with 12 months of treatment
  • Upper endoscopy to screen for varices should be performed if the LS is >20 kPa by TE or the platelet count is ≤150,000/mm3
  • Bone density examinations should be performed to exclude osteopenia or osteoporosis at diagnosis and at 2‐year to 3‐year intervals thereafter based on risk factors

Related blog posts:

Disclaimer: This blog, gutsandgrowth, assumes no responsibility for any use or operation of any method, product, instruction, concept or idea contained in the material herein or for any injury or damage to persons or property (whether products liability, negligence or otherwise) resulting from such use or operation. These blog posts are for educational purposes only. Specific dosing of medications (along with potential adverse effects) should be confirmed by prescribing physician.  Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, the gutsandgrowth blog cautions that independent verification should be made of diagnosis and drug dosages. The reader is solely responsible for the conduct of any suggested test or procedure.  This content is not a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment provided by a qualified healthcare provider. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a condition.

How to Lower Pediatric Liver Transplantation Waitlist Mortality

From the editorial, Key Points:

  • Esmati et al.1 present a fascinating analysis of the impact on waitlist outcomes of a 2014 Eurotransplant (ET) policy that prioritizes patients younger than the age of 2 years with biliary atresia for deceased donor liver transplantation (DDLT) offers
  • Waitlist mortality decreased from 6.7% before to 2.3% after implementation of the new policy. Unexpectedly, this was not associated with an increase in DDLTs
  • During the same time period, the proportion of young patients with BA who underwent living donor liver transplantation (LDLT) increased from 55% to 74%.
  • Without adaptions to the pediatric Model for End‐Stage Liver Disease (MELD) or Pediatric End‐Stage Liver Disease scores, children can never fairly “compete” for deceased donor livers because of the tremendous volume and demand from the adult candidate list

My take (borrowed from editorial): There are many potential ways to achieve the desired goal of zero pediatric waitlist mortality. And, multiple strategies can successfully be pursued in parallel: prioritize children, increase use of LDLT, and increase/mandate use of split livers.

Related blog posts:

Another (unrelated) study in this issue -easy way to assess mobility (a key element of frailty) in adults with decompensated liver disease: AJ Groff et al. Liver Transplantation 29: 226-228. Open Access! A novel method using the level of mobility to predict mortality in patients admitted for decompensated cirrhosis: A prospective study The authors found the following: a value of <8 on The Johns Hopkins Highest Level of Mobility score (JH‐HLM, see below) was associated with much higher risk of mortality compared with those with a JH‐HLM score of 8.

GALA: Alagille Study

SM Vandriel et al. Hepatology 2023; 77: 512-529. Open Access! Natural history of liver disease in a large international cohort of children with Alagille syndrome: Results from the GALA study

This was a very large retrospective study (with more than 90 authors) with 1433 children.

Key findings:

  • Only 40.3% of children reach adulthood with their native liver; 54.4% had their native liver at 10 years of life
  • “It is noteworthy that bile duct paucity was reported in only 65% of liver biopsies performed during the first 3 months of life, the period during which there are diagnostic challenges with distinguishing ALGS from syndromic BA.” Thus, with a liver biopsy, there is a significant risk of misdiagnosis
  • The all‐cause mortality rate was 8.5%
  • The total bilirubin level between 6-12 months of life had significant predictive value. In the associated editorial: “The authors reported that 79% of patients with median TB of <5.0 mg/dL..reached adulthood with their native livers, whereas only 31.6% and 18.2% of patients with median TB levels between” 5-10 and >10 mg/dL survived into adulthood with their native livers.
  • The editorial makes the point that this data will be helpful and ongoing studies will be needed to determine the effectiveness of novel treatments (e.g. IBAT inhibitors)

My take: This is a very useful study in understanding the long term outcomes of Alagille syndrome.

Related blog posts:

Sandy Springs, GA

How Low Can You Go with Split Livers?

Z Wang et al. Liver Transplantation 2023; 29: 58-66. Outcome of split-liver transplantation from pediatric donors weighing 25 kg or less

DJ Stoltz et al. Liver Transplantation 2023; 29: 3-4.(Editorial) Open Access! Exploring the lower weight limit of splitable liver grafts for pediatric recipients

From the editorial:

“In this issue of Liver Transplantation, Wang et al.7 describe the results of an innovative strategy to increase organ availability, particularly for low‐weight pediatric recipients, by utilizing a low‐weight donor population (≤25 kg) that historically has been avoided in pediatric split‐liver transplantation (SLT)…They found no significant differences in perioperative data, postoperative complications, patient survival, or graft survival between SLTs from donors ≤25 kg and the other three groups.”

Implications of study findings:

  • Splitting livers from donors weighing less than 25 kg will increase the pediatric donor pool and could improve waitlist mortality
  • Split smaller livers may mitigate “the clinical consequences of large‐for‐size syndrome and subsequent graft dysfunction”
  • “This approach requires a substantial level of surgical expertise to achieve comparable outcomes with more conventional operative techniques”
  • “1‐year graft survival for pediatric recipients receiving technical variant grafts was significantly worse at low‐volume centers performing an average of <5 pediatric liver transplantations per year” compared with high‐volume centers (89.9% vs. 95.3%; p < 0.001)
  • Limitations: Retrospective study. Also, only 22 of the split livers were from <25 kg donors

My take: Making the best use of this precious resource is a solemn responsibility. This study provides another reason for more transplants to be done in centers with a high level of expertise and more reasons to continue to use split livers. In those with sufficient expertise, even smaller livers can save two lives instead of one.

Related blog posts: